US judge sets May trial date for $150m Baby Reindeer defamation case

Richard Gadd and Jessica Gunning in Baby Reindeer
A US federal judge has scheduled a May 2027 jury trial in Fiona Harvey’s US$150m defamation lawsuit against Netflix over its drama series Baby Reindeer, which she claims falsely portrayed her as a convicted stalker who sexually and physically assaulted the show’s creator, Richard Gadd.
Judge R Gary Klausner of the US District Court for the Central District of California has set May 18, 2027 as the start date for the trial, which will take place in LA. The decision comes after the case was put on hold for more than two years following an appeal by Netflix.
The court also established a series of pre-trial deadlines. Fact and expert discovery must be completed by February 17, with the deadline for filing motions set for March 3. A final pre-trial conference is scheduled for May 3, ahead of the jury trial beginning on May 18.
Harvey, a Scottish former lawyer, claims she was the inspiration for the character Martha Scott, who was played by Jessica Gunning. She argues Netflix presented a series of fabricated allegations about her as fact, despite opening the seven-part drama with the declaration: “This is a true story.”
In her original June 2024 complaint, Harvey alleged the series falsely depicted her as a twice-convicted stalker who was sentenced to five years in prison, sexually assaulted Gadd and attacked him with a glass. She also disputes the portrayal of Martha waiting outside Gadd’s home for up to 16 hours a day and stalking a police officer.
Harvey, who claims the show “destroyed her reputation, her character and her life,” says she has never been convicted of stalking or served a prison sentence. She argues that, despite the use of fictional names, viewers could identify her through several details in the series, leading to online harassment, reputational damage and emotional distress.
Her original lawsuit sought at least US$170m in damages, including compensation for reputational harm, emotional distress and lost earnings, as well as profits allegedly generated by the series. An amended complaint filed earlier this month seeks more than US$150m across three categories of damages, in addition to punitive damages, legal fees and interest.
Netflix has denied defaming Harvey, arguing the series is a dramatised account of Gadd’s experiences and that the underlying allegations of stalking and harassment were substantially true.
The streamer has also argued that Harvey failed to identify a provably false statement of fact about her, and that her reputation had already been damaged by reports of her alleged conduct prior to the show’s launch.
Gadd, who is not a defendant in the lawsuit, has previously said that Martha Scott is not Fiona Harvey, describing the series as an “emotionally true” dramatisation rather than a literal account of events.
The trial date was set after both parties submitted a joint request for a later start date of July 27, 2027. Judge Klausner instead opted for May 18.
This marks the latest step in a lawsuit that was the talk of the UK TV industry in 2024. In July of that year, Netflix moved to have the case dismissed. Two months later, Klausner rejected its attempt to have the lawsuit thrown out under California’s anti-SLAPP legislation, which is designed to protect free speech and prevent lawsuits intended to stifle public expression.
In his ruling, the judge said a reasonable viewer could understand the allegations about Martha to be about Harvey, despite the use of fictional names. He also drew a distinction between being accused of stalking and being convicted of stalking, as well as between inappropriate touching and sexual assault.
The judge allowed Harvey’s claims of defamation and intentional infliction of emotional distress to proceed, while dismissing her negligence, gross negligence and right-of-publicity claims, along with her request for punitive damages at that stage. The ruling did not establish that Netflix had defamed Harvey but allowed the central allegations to be tested in court.
Netflix appealed the decision in October 2024, triggering a stay of proceedings and the cancellation of an original May 2025 trial date. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal on jurisdictional grounds on October 23, 2026, allowing the case to return to the district court.
Harvey subsequently filed an amended complaint on November 3, 2026, expanding on her allegations and adding details that emerged after the original filing.
The case is being keenly observed by the television industry as a potential test of the legal responsibilities facing streamers and producers when dramatising real-life events, particularly where programmes are marketed as true stories and the people who inspire their characters remain identifiable.