Please wait...
Please wait...

Phillip Schofield review finds ITV ‘made considerable efforts to determine truth’

An independent external review into ITV in the UK’s handling of the accusations relating to presenter Phillip Schofield has found the commercial broadcaster’s management “made considerable efforts to determine the truth.”

Carolyn McCall

Schofield resigned from ITV earlier this year and admitted he had an “unwise but not illegal” relationship with a younger male colleague on This Morning and then lied about it to his colleagues, employer and talent agency.

Carolyn McCall, ITV CEO, subsequently called in Jane Mulcahy KC, a barrister from London’s Blackstone Chambers, to conduct an external review into the facts around the recent departure of Schofield.

Mulcahy’s review examined complaints by employees and freelancers working on This Morning from January 2016 and whether ITV’s response was appropriate and adequate.

Mulcahy stated that “in the face of the denials of the individuals involved, ITV was unable to uncover the relevant evidence until [Schofield]’s admission in late May 2023,” when Schofield admitted to the affair with the younger employee, who he had helped get a job at the network.

The KC also concluded that Schofield’s relationship with the employee, identified as Person X, had not unfairly advantaged the latter as his career progressed, while ITV had provided relevant support to Person X when media speculation regarding the affair first emerged in 2019.

Mulcahy noted that former junior employees did not report their knowledge of the affair at the time, nor did others report suspicions from much earlier in 2017, leading the KC to emphasise the importance of junior employees at ITV having the confidence to raise concerns to management in line with the broadcaster’s ‘Speaking Up’ policy.

“In particular, managers should ensure that all staff know there is a safe space to complain or raise concerns. No-one should be worried that their job will be at risk because they have raised an issue,” she said.

“I have no doubt that senior management are absolutely wedded to the importance of an open culture. But this culture is still not filtering down to junior employees, many of whom remain convinced that to speak out will have a detrimental impact on their careers.”

Mulcahy also suggested ITV set out clear guidelines for talent to “ensure that good behaviours are observed even by those who are household names,” while encouraging “more open, direct and straightforward communication” with freelancers.

The KC’s other recommendations included reviewing the structure of This Morning/Daytime to ensure close and centralised control of both production and editorial, revisiting the HR structure and increasing numbers of personnel where necessary, centralising information on employees and promoting the keeping of written records.

In response, ITV’s chairman Andy Cosslett said he “welcomed” the findings of the review and that the broadcaster is already acting on the recommendations.

“We are completely committed to creating an environment where everyone is treated with respect and feels able to give of their best. Our promise to those we work with is that where a complaint is made, or serious concerns raised, we will always investigate and if we find that something inappropriate has happened, we will take action,” Cosslett said.

“We will continue to develop our efforts to give junior colleagues the confidence to speak up if they have something to raise. I hope that the completion of this review allows the team at This Morning to get back to what they do so well, making a brilliant show that entertains and informs millions of viewers every week.”

RELATED ARTICLES

Please wait...